이 두 쿼리를 비교하십시오. 조인 기준이나 WHERE절 에 필터를 적용하는 것이 더 빠릅니까? 가능한 한 빨리 결과 세트를 줄이기 때문에 조인 기준에서 더 빠르다고 항상 느꼈지만 확실하지 않습니다.
나는 몇 가지 테스트를 만들어 볼 것이지만 또한 어떤 것이 더 명확하게 읽을 수 있는지에 대한 의견을 얻고 싶었습니다.
쿼리 1
SELECT *
FROM TableA a
INNER JOIN TableXRef x
ON a.ID = x.TableAID
INNER JOIN TableB b
ON x.TableBID = b.ID
WHERE a.ID = 1 /* <-- Filter here? */쿼리 2
SELECT *
FROM TableA a
INNER JOIN TableXRef x
ON a.ID = x.TableAID
AND a.ID = 1 /* <-- Or filter here? */
INNER JOIN TableB b
ON x.TableBID = b.ID편집하다
몇 가지 테스트를 실행 한 결과 결과는 실제로 매우 가깝지만 WHERE절은 실제로 약간 더 빠릅니다! =)
WHERE절에 필터를 적용하는 것이 더 합리적이라는 데 절대적으로 동의합니다 . 성능에 미치는 영향에 대해 궁금했습니다.
ELAPSED TIME WHERE CRITERIA : 143016 ms
ELAPSED TIME JOIN CRITERIA : 143256 ms
테스트
SET NOCOUNT ON;
DECLARE @num INT,
@iter INT
SELECT @num = 1000, -- Number of records in TableA and TableB, the cross table is populated with a CROSS JOIN from A to B
@iter = 1000 -- Number of select iterations to perform
DECLARE @a TABLE (
id INT
)
DECLARE @b TABLE (
id INT
)
DECLARE @x TABLE (
aid INT,
bid INT
)
DECLARE @num_curr INT
SELECT @num_curr = 1
WHILE (@num_curr <= @num)
BEGIN
INSERT @a (id) SELECT @num_curr
INSERT @b (id) SELECT @num_curr
SELECT @num_curr = @num_curr + 1
END
INSERT @x (aid, bid)
SELECT a.id,
b.id
FROM @a a
CROSS JOIN @b b
/*
TEST
*/
DECLARE @begin_where DATETIME,
@end_where DATETIME,
@count_where INT,
@begin_join DATETIME,
@end_join DATETIME,
@count_join INT,
@curr INT,
@aid INT
DECLARE @temp TABLE (
curr INT,
aid INT,
bid INT
)
DELETE FROM @temp
SELECT @curr = 0,
@aid = 50
SELECT @begin_where = CURRENT_TIMESTAMP
WHILE (@curr < @iter)
BEGIN
INSERT @temp (curr, aid, bid)
SELECT @curr,
aid,
bid
FROM @a a
INNER JOIN @x x
ON a.id = x.aid
INNER JOIN @b b
ON x.bid = b.id
WHERE a.id = @aid
SELECT @curr = @curr + 1
END
SELECT @end_where = CURRENT_TIMESTAMP
SELECT @count_where = COUNT(1) FROM @temp
DELETE FROM @temp
SELECT @curr = 0
SELECT @begin_join = CURRENT_TIMESTAMP
WHILE (@curr < @iter)
BEGIN
INSERT @temp (curr, aid, bid)
SELECT @curr,
aid,
bid
FROM @a a
INNER JOIN @x x
ON a.id = x.aid
AND a.id = @aid
INNER JOIN @b b
ON x.bid = b.id
SELECT @curr = @curr + 1
END
SELECT @end_join = CURRENT_TIMESTAMP
SELECT @count_join = COUNT(1) FROM @temp
DELETE FROM @temp
SELECT @count_where AS count_where,
@count_join AS count_join,
DATEDIFF(millisecond, @begin_where, @end_where) AS elapsed_where,
DATEDIFF(millisecond, @begin_join, @end_join) AS elapsed_join